diff --git a/static/crossroad.html b/static/crossroad.html
index d303d16..8ca3031 100644
--- a/static/crossroad.html
+++ b/static/crossroad.html
@@ -30,7 +30,17 @@
                         instance.<br>
                         <img src="/static/down_arrow.svg" alt="" class="medium-height" />
                         <p id="noInstance">You currently don't have any instances. You should add one!</p>
-                        <form id="instanceSelectForm" class="align-start wfit-content"></form>
+                        <form id="instanceSelectForm" class="align-start wfit-content">
+                            <ol id="preferredList" class="margin-none" hidden></ol>
+                            <div id="forks" hidden>
+                                <p class="align-center margin-none-bottom">Other <span id="forkOf"></span> forks</p>
+                                <ol id="forksList" class="margin-none"></ol>
+                            </div>
+                            <div id="others" hidden>
+                                <p class="align-center margin-none-bottom">Other instances</p>
+                                <ol id="othersList" class="margin-none"></ol>
+                            </div>
+                        </form>
                         <br>
                         <button id="startAddInstanceFlow">Add an instance</button>
                     </center>
diff --git a/static/crossroad.mts b/static/crossroad.mts
index 94ab9eb..a525f19 100644
--- a/static/crossroad.mts
+++ b/static/crossroad.mts
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 import { AddInstanceFlow } from "./add_instance_flow.mjs";
-import { findButtonOrFail, findDialogOrFail, findFormOrFail, findInputOrFail, findParagraphOrFail, findPreOrFail, findSpanOrFail } from "./dom.mjs";
+import { findButtonOrFail, findDialogOrFail, findDivOrFail, findFormOrFail, findInputOrFail, findOlOrFail, findParagraphOrFail, findPreOrFail, findSpanOrFail } from "./dom.mjs";
 import knownSoftware, { getName } from "./known_software.mjs";
-import storageManager from "./storage_manager.mjs";
+import storageManager, { Instance } from "./storage_manager.mjs";
 
 const RADIO_BUTTON_NAME = "instanceSelect";
 
@@ -13,6 +13,12 @@ const addDialog = findDialogOrFail(document.body, "#addInstance");
 const spinnerDialog = findDialogOrFail(document.body, "#spinner");
 const detailsDialog = findDialogOrFail(document.body, "#instanceDetails");
 const instanceSelectForm = findFormOrFail(document.body, "#instanceSelectForm");
+const preferredList = findOlOrFail(document.body, "#preferredList");
+const forksDiv = findDivOrFail(document.body, "#forks");
+const forkOfSpan = findSpanOrFail(document.body, "#forkOf");
+const forksList = findOlOrFail(document.body, "#forksList");
+const othersDiv = findDivOrFail(document.body, "#others");
+const othersList = findOlOrFail(document.body, "#othersList");
 const redirectButton = findButtonOrFail(document.body, "#redirect");
 const redirectAlwaysButton = findButtonOrFail(document.body, "#redirectAlways");
 const noInstanceParagraph = findParagraphOrFail(document.body, "#noInstance");
@@ -58,34 +64,112 @@ function updateNoInstanceHint() {
         storageManager.storage.instances.length > 0;
 }
 
-function createInstanceSelectOptions() {
-    instanceSelectForm.replaceChildren(); // Erase all child nodes
-    for (const instance of storageManager.storage.instances) {
-        const div = document.createElement("div");
-        div.setAttribute("x-option", instance.origin);
-        const radio = document.createElement("input");
-        radio.id = instance.origin;
-        radio.value = instance.origin;
-        radio.type = "radio";
-        radio.name = RADIO_BUTTON_NAME;
-        const label = document.createElement("label");
-        label.htmlFor = instance.origin;
-        label.innerText = instance.name + " ";
-        if (instance.iconURL) {
-            const img = new Image();
-            img.src = instance.iconURL;
-            img.alt = `${instance.name} icon`;
-            img.className = "inlineIcon medium-height";
-            label.append(img, " ");
+type PreferenceGroups = {
+    preferred: Instance[],
+    forks?: {
+        list: Instance[],
+        of: string,
+    },
+    others: Instance[],
+};
+
+function sortInstancesIntoPreferenceGroups(): PreferenceGroups {
+    const targetID = getTargetSoftwareOrGroup();
+    const pGroups: PreferenceGroups = {
+        preferred: [],
+        others: [],
+    };
+    // If targetID is a group
+    if (knownSoftware.groups[targetID]) {
+        for (const instance of storageManager.storage.instances) {
+            const software = knownSoftware.software[instance.software];
+            // If the instance's software is in the target group
+            if (software.groups.includes(targetID)) {
+                pGroups.preferred.push(instance);
+            } else {
+                pGroups.others.push(instance);
+            }
+        }
+    } else {
+        const isFork = knownSoftware.software[targetID].forkOf !== undefined;
+        const forkOf = knownSoftware.software[targetID].forkOf ?? targetID;
+        const hasForks = isFork || Object.values(knownSoftware.software).some(s => s.forkOf === forkOf);
+        if (hasForks) {
+            pGroups.forks = {
+                list: [],
+                of: forkOf,
+            };
+        }
+        for (const instance of storageManager.storage.instances) {
+            if (instance.software === targetID) {
+                pGroups.preferred.push(instance);
+                continue;
+            }
+            const software = knownSoftware.software[instance.software];
+            // Checking pGroups.forks is the TypeScript safe way of checking hasForks
+            if (pGroups.forks && (instance.software === forkOf || software.forkOf === forkOf)) {
+                pGroups.forks.list.push(instance);
+                continue;
+            }
+            pGroups.others.push(instance);
         }
-        const small = document.createElement("small");
-        const softwareName = knownSoftware.software[instance.software].name;
-        small.innerText = `(${softwareName})`;
-        label.appendChild(small);
-        div.appendChild(radio);
-        div.appendChild(label);
-        instanceSelectForm.appendChild(div);
     }
+    return pGroups;
+}
+
+function constructOptionFromInstance(instance: Instance): HTMLDivElement {
+    const div = document.createElement("div");
+    div.setAttribute("x-option", instance.origin);
+    const radio = document.createElement("input");
+    radio.id = instance.origin;
+    radio.value = instance.origin;
+    radio.type = "radio";
+    radio.name = RADIO_BUTTON_NAME;
+    const label = document.createElement("label");
+    label.htmlFor = instance.origin;
+    label.innerText = instance.name + " ";
+    if (instance.iconURL) {
+        const img = new Image();
+        img.src = instance.iconURL;
+        img.alt = `${instance.name} icon`;
+        img.className = "inlineIcon medium-height";
+        label.append(img, " ");
+    }
+    const small = document.createElement("small");
+    const softwareName = knownSoftware.software[instance.software].name;
+    small.innerText = `(${softwareName})`;
+    label.appendChild(small);
+    div.appendChild(radio);
+    div.appendChild(label);
+    return div;
+}
+
+function createInstanceSelectOptions() {
+    // Erase all child nodes
+    preferredList.replaceChildren();
+    forksList.replaceChildren();
+    othersList.replaceChildren();
+
+    const { preferred, forks, others } = sortInstancesIntoPreferenceGroups();
+
+    preferredList.hidden = preferred.length === 0;
+    for (const instance of preferred) {
+        preferredList.appendChild(constructOptionFromInstance(instance));
+    }
+
+    forksDiv.hidden = forks === undefined;
+    if (forks) {
+        forkOfSpan.innerText = getName(knownSoftware, forks.of) ?? forks.of;
+        for (const instance of forks.list) {
+            forksList.appendChild(constructOptionFromInstance(instance));
+        }
+    }
+
+    othersDiv.hidden = others.length === 0;
+    for (const instance of others) {
+        othersList.appendChild(constructOptionFromInstance(instance));
+    }
+
     const firstInput = instanceSelectForm.querySelector("input");
     if (firstInput) firstInput.checked = true;
     setRedirectButtonState(firstInput !== null);
diff --git a/static/dom.mts b/static/dom.mts
index aec7536..a4bf983 100644
--- a/static/dom.mts
+++ b/static/dom.mts
@@ -1,6 +1,13 @@
 // I would've LOVED to use generics for this but unfortunately that's not possible.
 // Type safety, but at what cost... >~< thanks TypeScript
 
+export function findDivOrFail(on: Element, selector: string): HTMLDivElement {
+    const element = on.querySelector(selector);
+    if (!(element instanceof HTMLDivElement))
+        throw new Error(`${selector} isn't a div`);
+    return element;
+}
+
 export function findSpanOrFail(on: Element, selector: string): HTMLSpanElement {
     const element = on.querySelector(selector);
     if (!(element instanceof HTMLSpanElement))
diff --git a/static/main.css b/static/main.css
index 517e16f..bc6e75a 100644
--- a/static/main.css
+++ b/static/main.css
@@ -61,6 +61,10 @@ abbr[title] {
     text-align: start;
 }
 
+.align-center {
+    text-align: center;
+}
+
 .inline-block {
     display: inline-block;
 }
@@ -157,6 +161,10 @@ abbr[title] {
     margin-bottom: var(--large);
 }
 
+.margin-none-bottom {
+    margin-bottom: 0;
+}
+
 .square {
     aspect-ratio: 1;
 }